30

Apr

11:33pm
Srutayu Bhattacharya India
"Stolen by the Rich": Capitalism and European Football

"Stolen by the Rich": Capitalism and European Football

Srutayu Bhattacharya India//11:33pm, Apr 30th '21

Last week, European football supporters have issued a clarion call to discard the proposal of the newly planned European Super League(ESL) orchestrated by the owners of the elite clubs. Their anger is directed against the greedy pursuit of money as well as the betrayal against the traditional values. Such references to greed and money can easily be translated along the lines of capitalist notion of profit. Although the reaction against this proposed breakaway league is genuinely justified the existing European league systems as well as the UEFA tournaments do not hold any holier stand. The ever growing European football industry is the perfect manifestation of how football capitalism runs through the world.

The qualitative shift in the European football industry in the last decade of the twentieth century is marked by the concentration of capital/wealth. With the foundation of the Premiership in England in 1992 a massive change has been materialized. Thatcher’seconomic reforms like deregulation of public sectors make England embrace free-market. This pre-condition leads to the culmination when 20 top English football clubs enter into a breakaway division and make a statement by dealing with Rupert Murdoch’s BSkyB as television broadcaster. On one hand this move generates a flow of huge money at the top tier; on the other, it effectively marks a radical imbalance between the Premier League and the Football League in terms of income. Also many clubs take this opportunity to float on the stock exchange. Merchandising, inflation in stadium tickets bring changes in traditional football economy and culture as with television rights football very much cements its place into the global network of capitalism. While the division’s wealth lures the best players and managers of the world it also entices the rich billionaires to come and invest in this league. So sporting success basically owes much to the possession of money and this prepares the ground of rampant inequality where the rich becomes richer and the smaller clubs cannot compete with them. In Premier League the picture remains unchanged for almost three decades where the wealthy clubs like Manchester United, Arsenal, Chelsea and Manchester City (recently Liverpool too) have divided league titles between them with notable exceptions like Blackburn Rovers (1995) and Leicester City (2016). Similar elite league competitions like Seria A, La Liga and Bundesligaalong with the UEFA Champions League (Europe’s top competition) mirror the exact scenario. Therefore, sporting success becomes synonymous to the buying power of the clubs.

With such a promising revenue generating industry booming corporate investors starts taking over clubs or buying stakes or controlling shares in elite European leagues. Within the first fifteen years of twenty first century American sports franchise owners like Glazers (Tampa Bay Buccaneers), Gillete (Montreal Canadiens) & Hicks (Texas Rangers), J.W. Henry (Boston Red Sox), Thomas di Benedetto (Boston Red Sox), Eric Thohir (DC United) flockto English and Italian football as they respectively become owners or shareholders of glorious traditional clubs like Manchester United, Liverpool, AS Romaand Internazionale. On the other hand, Russian oligarch like Roman Abramovich or oil-rich Arab owner Sheikh Mansour or the Qatari Investment Authority massively changes the history of success of Chelsea, Manchester City and PSG. In sponsorship deals sovereign wealth funds like Fly Emirates (Arsenal) and Qatar Foundation (Barcelona) or in tie ups with huge corporate organizations like Audi (Bayern Munchen) the billionaires take the hot seat. This marks a rupture in the traditional supporter-based (mostly from the working class) football culture; although the duality exists as the yearning to attractglory never wanes. Stadium tickets remain no more the primary concern of such businessmen; a global consumer base that devours the market-products as well as the global coverage becomes the centre of attention to them.

The Nineties marks the beginning of the era when the wage ratio between average European elite footballer and average male starts to change drastically¬– the figure that stands at 5:1 in 1990 (before global coverage)reaches at 48:1 in 2010.However players with their brands, sponsorship and insured body-parts become almost commodity-like figures. Europe imports ships of players from all around Africa and South America and the concerned federations are given financial aids due to such moves. On the other hand, with the spread of global coverage, jerseys and other product sales, establishment of fan-clubs European elite clubs are able to create huge consumer-market in Asia and Africa.In such a way Europe controls the whole market economy of the world football. However, Inequality is deeply rooted within the financial structures of it’s own footballing system. The so-called competitiveness that it boasts about appears quite delusional as money controls the game; although chance factors of smaller teams never cease completely because of the game’s own logic where the powerful can be challenged by the weaker sides within 90 minutes.

ESL, the proposed breakaway league that comes with a ‘closed shop’ model with only top 15 elite teams participating without any provision of relegation chooses to limit the concept of ‘competitiveness’ within fixed boundary– by pitting only big teams against themselves every week. The organizers eye the maximum profit from it. In the whole European league system(and in UEFA tournaments) there exists kind of a commitment (in terms of a systematic revenue sharing) to the participating teams (including the smaller ones) where participation for some teams alters through the cycle of promotion and relegation. ESL threatens that sense of commitment too. This attempt by the elite clubs to monopolize the market has been inevitable although ultimately it faces strong denial from the supporter-base. However, the alternative existing model of reformed version of UEFA tournaments too are not beyond suspicion. This is a trend that attempts to put the commercialization of the game at centre to make maximum profits and in the way these capitalists try to take away the game from the working class people.

WITHIN THE WALLS: A memoir of the plague in Quebec City
Luis Lazaro Tijerina USA//7:40pm, Mar 12th '22

WITHIN THE WALLS: A memoir of the plague in Quebec City

Chapter V PART IV: My Caput Galeatum, and the Divine Québec SceneryIt is well known that the old walls of the Citadelle, including the first fort to be built on the high cliff known as Cape Diamond, would....

Read More
The Marriage of Scientology and Capitalism
Megan Sherman UK//8:51pm, Mar 1st '22

The Marriage of Scientology and Capitalism

For the scammers and charlatans who became the vanguard of Scientology, truth is the enemy and the agenda reflects only one voice, sociopath David Miscavidge.I watched in horror the Louis Theroux film....

Read More
COCHABAMBA WATER WAR: The Effects of Privatization of Water Supply
Sumedha Chatterjee Ireland//10:44pm, Nov 14th '21

COCHABAMBA WATER WAR: The Effects of Privatization of Water Supply

As the world we are living in becomes increasingly globalized, we see the traditional roles of the state to be ebbing. The lines between state and non state activities shall blur to an extent that there....

Read More
Music as an expression of protest against class and racial segregation- part 3 of 4
Gordan Stosevic Slovenia//10:40am, Dec 9th '21

Music as an expression of protest against class and racial segregation- part 3 of 4

A glaring example is associated with jazz diva Billy Holiday, who became the target of Federal Bureau of Investigation chief Harry J. Enslinger. He seeked an official ban on all her public appearances....

Read More
From trade unions to farmers' strike: India on its way to mass revolt
Debojit Banerjee India//8:52pm, Dec 6th '20

From trade unions to farmers' strike: India on its way to mass revolt

Being a citizen of India, I am inclined to compare our economy with a coin which has 102 billionaires as it’s “Heads” who are getting busy everyday in living their sumptuous lives and 0.9 billion....

Read More
Most of The Canadian Left Smears China to Deflect from our Colonial History of Genocide
Aidan Jonah.Canada //3:35pm, Jan 24th '21

Most of The Canadian Left Smears China to Deflect from our Colonial History of Genocide

The dominant image of China pushed by Canadian media figures is that of an evil imperialist nation. If you had of asked me what I thought of China when I was first starting up The Canada Files, I would’ve....

Read More