10

Jan

7:13pm
Owen Williamson USA
Kazakhstan in Crisis:  How to Marxists make sense of it?

Kazakhstan in Crisis: How to Marxists make sense of it?

Owen Williamson USA //7:13pm, Jan 10th '22

In recent days, unexpected civil unrest in the former Soviet republic of Kazakhstan has confused many international observers, particularly those who are seeking some sort of a class-based explanation for what is happening in that country. Media coverage of the spontaneous revolt that has shaken that country features up to now very little identifiable division of forces between “progressives” or “the left” on the one hand, vs. conservative or right-wing elements on the other, no clear revolutionary agendas or platforms, and little or nothing in the way of coherent programmes or demands on any side. According to a January, 2022 report from Russia’s Zanovo Media, as translated and published by the American online journal Jacobin, “Underground” Resistance organizations such as the Socialist Movement of Kazakhstan (Социалистического движения Казахстана) have so far had no on-the-ground leadership role in the protests.

Factors involved

According to reports, the current level of unrest in Kazakhstan involves internal factors including:

  • Most immediately, fuel price increases;
  • Ongoing lack of internal democracy, a political system described as “autocratic” and rigid; No effective avenue for peaceful protest;
  • Inflation, unemployment and impoverishment;
  • Economic disruption caused by COVID.
  • Image

    External factors fanning the protests include:

  • Geopolitical pressures, including intense pressures from Western Europe to continue an uninterrupted supply of oil to pipelines, and from Russia, to suppress any possible “color revolution” in Kazakhstan like that in Ukraine;
  • If you read our blogs then why not our magazine!!!
    Image
    Click here to subscribe our monthly magazine
  • Western interest in maintaining geopolitical pressure on Russia, particularly in the immediate context of the current Russia/Ukraine armed standoff;
  • Various types of foreign Islamist pressure, either from nearby Afghanistan, Pakistan and Iran, or from further afield (e.g., Wahabi influence from Saudi Arabia; radical Islamist ideology from foreign groups like Daesh [“ISIS”] and Al Qaeda).
  • As has been widely reported in mainstream capitalist media, the spark for the current unrest was a doubling of prices for LPG (Liquified Petroleum Gas, the most commonly used automobile fuel in Kazakhstan). Kazakhstan is oil-rich, but in the post-Soviet era the country’s oil wealth has been sold off to private companies, mostly Western. Thus, the country’s government no longer controls the sale price of petroleum and gas products.

    Image

    For almost 29 years, from the breakup of the USSR in 1990, until March of 2019, Kazakhstan was ruled by Nursultan Nazarbayev (Нурсултан Абишевич Назарбаев), former Prime Minister of the former Kazakh SSR. His ruling style might be described as Soviet-like, but utterly without the Soviets’ socialist ideals (Communist discipline, equality, workers’ power) or high ethics (in fact, credible allegations have been made that Nazarbayev and family have vastly enriched themselves by selling off the nation’s wealth). The current president, Kassym-Jomart Tokayev ( Касым-Жомарт Кемелевич Токаев), took office in 2019 upon Nazarbayev’s resignation.

    Sources for more information:

    For the best currently available English-medium Marxist background analysis of the daily-changing situation in Kazakhstan, one should look at the online “Statement of the Socialist Movement of Kazakhstan on the situation in the country” on the http://socialism.kz website expresses the viewpoint of the country’s Marxist opposition. The original online article is in Russian, and an English-speaker may have to use an online translation-program. A January 9, 2022 English-language article in the Jerusalem Post, “Israel and Kazakhstan: When bland Foreign Ministry statement says it all,” explains a great deal of the larger global geopolitical context behind Kazakhstan’s current crisis, albeit from a Zionist point of view that some readers may well find unacceptable. One may also consult Jacobin magazine’s January, 2022 article, “Kazakhstan’s Protests are About Soaring Inequality for further analysis.


    Two Speeches – Two Worldviews
    Christopher Black Canada//9:36pm, Dec 29th '22

    Two Speeches – Two Worldviews

    On March 5th, 1946, Winston Churchill delivered his famous Sinews of Peace speech in Fulton Missouri in which he famously claimed that, “an Iron Curtain has descended across Europe.”  The essential....

    Read More
    On Dialectical and Historical Materialism: Part 1
    Turner Roth USA//10:23pm, Apr 19th '23

    On Dialectical and Historical Materialism: Part 1

    The following essay comprises the text of a lecture given in July of 2022 at the Communist Party USA’s Little Red Schoolhouse, a yearly summer school based at the CPUSA headquarters in New York City.IntroductionHistorical....

    Read More
    As the Queen Departs, the Country Demands the Return of British loot: The Kohinoor
    Saurav Dutt//11:32pm, Sep 16th '22

    As the Queen Departs, the Country Demands the Return of British loot: The Kohinoor

    The Kohinoor Diamond represents subjugation and supremacy, it’s time to return it.In the wake of the passing of Her Royal Majesty Queen Elizabeth II audiences have been dazzled by images of the Imperial....

    Read More
    The Axis of Resistance and its Historical Presence in the Middle East and Beyond
    Luis Lazaro Tijerina USA//8:54pm, Sep 30th '24

    The Axis of Resistance and its Historical Presence in the Middle East and Beyond

    The historical presence of the Axis of Resistance (known in Persian as محور مقاومت Mehvar-e Moqâvemat and in Arabic as محور المقاومة Miḥwar al-Muqāwamah) in West Asia and North....

    Read More
    In Rich Germany: Even More Mini Jobs
    Werner Rugemer//1:10am, Nov 17th '21

    In Rich Germany: Even More Mini Jobs

    The new government to be formed in wealthy Germany wants to divide work into many more small jobs and the profiteers of the Corona policy are rejoicing. "We want to make mini-jobs more attractive": despite....

    Read More
    Torture in the Heat of History: A Polemic Against Israel
    R.C. Roberts USA//6:59pm, Jun 1st '21

    Torture in the Heat of History: A Polemic Against Israel

    Israel is a country that, when you get down to it, is little more than the left over pretension of British colonialism, hopped up on narcotic of unquestioning American support, and covered in the hush-toned....

    Read More