13

Nov

5:14pm
George Chakma India
The Hills and the State : A Glance at the Art of not Being Governed

The Hills and the State : A Glance at the Art of not Being Governed

George Chakma India//5:14pm, Nov 13th '21

For most of human history, the majority of human beings lived outside state control or authority, ‘’under loose-knit empires or in situations of fragmented sovereignty’’. It is only in the last few centuries that such non state spaces have increasingly shrunk and people living there have been incorporated into the populace of nation states, which have become hegemonic units of sovereignty. Today, it may seem odd to even imagine human civilization without any form of state, from kingdoms to modern nation states. Yet, living outside the authority of state was at some point a choice, that was political in nature, made my millions of people across the world. One such space is located in mainland southeast Asia. The areas above 300 or so meters in altitude in this region has been one of the largest non-state populations. James C. Scott in his work ‘’The art of not being governed: an anarchist history of southeast Asia’’ makes this very fascinating argument. The book and the arguments(s) that he makes are like a refreshing breeze that offers a critical departure from the more usual liberal/state-centric ways and theories of studying, especially the social spaces of what we call the natives or the indigenous peoples across the world.

Image

The first chapter of the book is more than just a primer. One of the longest chapters in the entire book, it offers an overview of all the major arguments that are made in rest of the chapters. The above-mentioned social space in the southeast Asian mastiff has been termed ‘Zomia’. ‘Zo’ in many languages in the region (including kuki and Mizo) refers to people and ‘Mi’ refers to land. The term first coined by Wilhelm Van schendel, is used extensively by James Scott. As the name suggests, he develops an anarchist theory of the said region. He states that Zomia and her people have historically lived as peripheries to the classical kingdoms, which were exclusively centered in the valleys. They practiced shifting cultivation and kept constantly moving from place to place. He develops the theory that these people, who are considered as residue of civilization, or barbarians, backwards and what not, are actually contemporaneous to other settled civilizations. It was in fact a political choice that they made to live outside the control of the state. They are what can be called runaway people who refused to pay taxes to the state. Tax in the form of grain forms the central concern of James Scott’s theory. They instead chose to cultivate untaxable or difficult to tax produces like roots and fruits. Over a period of time, they developed distinct identities, languages and cultures. The region ended up becoming one of more diverse areas of the world. Colonial powers, when they tried to annex these areas had a hard time rendering legible the ways of life of the people. Post-colonial nation states as well were faced with the same obstacle. Armed struggle to the post-colonial sovereigns by the people of Zomia has been one of the popular strategies to resist all pervasive internal colonialism.

If you read our blogs then why not our magazine!!!
Image
Click here to subscribe our monthly magazine

Political control over zomia, argues James Scott in the second chapter, runs out of breath when faced with the ‘friction of distance’. Humans are popularly believed to be land dominating species. But, a more historically grounded observation reveals that they travel the farthest and exert influence the greatest across water bodies than land mass. The kingdoms of the valleys had more similarities with lands hundreds of miles away than the hills that surround them. In fact, the region is so distinctly diverse that Jacobs Julian in his study of present say Nagaland had called it an ‘ethnographic mess’. This is generalizable across the world. The Roman empire was essentially a Mediterranean empire and not European, as argued by Fernand Braudel in his work ‘’The Mediterranean world’’. It is only the arbitrariness imposed by modern colonial powers and nation sates that otherwise historically entangled cultures are divided and artificial civilizational boundaries are created. In ‘black Athena: the Afro-asiatic roots of classical civilizations’, Martin Bernal argues how the roots of Greek civilization was Asia and Africa and not mainland Europe. As a consequence, the ‘history less’ run away people are integrated into the understanding of nation. The process is without fail violent: direct and otherwise. Such groups of people can be found round the world. The people of the Amazons in south America to escape the state climbed down the mountains into the more inhospitable dense forests. The Berbers of North Africa chose to live in the desert rather than pay taxes and live under state authority. Ernest Gellner calls it ‘Marginal tribalism’.

Image

Most modern theories of state and sovereignty do gross injustice to Zomia and other similar spaces. State centric understanding of sovereignty coupled with formation of states around the core of the classical kingdoms has made the people of Zomia the other. James Scott suggest the sankritic theory of Mandala to understand the elementary units of political order. Sovereignty in this region of the world was not strictly defined as was in Europe. The existence of dual sovereignty may bewilder European scholars. Kingdoms were rather loosely defined circles of influence that most of the time intersect each other. In Zomia, villages were mostly the political units. Mandala theory is in fact gaining popularity among decolonial scholars like Aditya Nigam, who concern themselves with the study of non-European spaces and ways of being. Thanks to state mimicry, the ‘village states’ of Zomia at times grew bigger than village as the political unit and took shape of some sort of clan-based rule. James Scott calls it cosmological bluster. These rules had only the rudimentary materials of the Indic or the Chinese kingdoms.

The art of not being governed with its materially grounded study offers a quintessentially anarchist approach to the study of Zomia. The hills of Zomia stood in a dialectical relation with the valleys. While historically the two socio-geographical spaces did have interdependent economic and cultural ties, it was never a relation of authority. The free people of Zomia offered a non-state centric definition of sovereignty by willingly taking the political decision of not being governed.

AN INSIGHT INTO THE ENERGY CRISIS IN THE UK
Sumedha Chatterjee Ireland//6:28pm, Feb 11th '22

AN INSIGHT INTO THE ENERGY CRISIS IN THE UK

‘THE GREAT ENERGY RIP-OFF’ published by the Communist Party UK makes a reasonable plea for the nationalization of the energy industry. Written by Stewart McGill and Richard Shillcock (Stewart McGill....

Read More
A Military Theory of the Ukranian Army, Its History, Strengths, And Weaknesses During the ‘‘SPECIAL MILITARY OPERATION’’ of 2022
Luis Lazaro Tijerina USA//1:19pm, Jun 23rd '22

A Military Theory of the Ukranian Army, Its History, Strengths, And Weaknesses During the ‘‘SPECIAL MILITARY OPERATION’’ of 2022

IntroductionAt a time of war in Europe and widespread concern that the conflict could spread, it is important to have a clear view of matters, yet more than ever we are subject to a mass of propaganda....

Read More
Against ‘‘CAPITALIST REALISM’’ and the ‘‘NEOLIBERAL STATE’’
Megan Sherman//12:38am, Mar 11th '22

Against ‘‘CAPITALIST REALISM’’ and the ‘‘NEOLIBERAL STATE’’

Capitalist realism is the official ideology of the neoliberal state, and is an insidious form of propaganda that seeks to eliminate resistance to regressive corporate tyranny. “Capitalist Realism,”....

Read More
Taiwan: US deployment area against mainland China - since 1945
Werner Rugemer Germany//9:28pm, Nov 28th '21

Taiwan: US deployment area against mainland China - since 1945

Under U.S. guidance, the regime of Generalissimo Chiang Kai-Shek was installed in Taiwan beginning in 1945: He had already been supported by the USA in the 1920s, then also by Hitler's Germany. Taiwan....

Read More
The Entertainment Propaganda Machine
Tarik Ata Great Britain//2:00am, Apr 5th '22

The Entertainment Propaganda Machine

Propaganda is something we in the West often associate with Nazi Germany and the likes of Joseph Goebbels or even that of the Soviet Union — often incorrectly equating the USSR to the Nazi regime in....

Read More
ENDSARS PROTESTS IN NIGERIA: SYMPTOMS OF A DEEP AND UNDERLINING SOCIAL MALAISE
Clarius Ugwuoha Nigeria//5:30pm, Oct 31st '20

ENDSARS PROTESTS IN NIGERIA: SYMPTOMS OF A DEEP AND UNDERLINING SOCIAL MALAISE

Quite recently, Nigeria came under the grips of what could be termed, the Post Pandemic Stress Syndrome (PPSS). Months of seclusion, hunger and uncertainty had drastically lowered the threshold of tolerance....

Read More